Brown vs. Black Mascara: Which Mascara Colour Should You Choose?

We all know that perfect swipe of mascara can transform our entire look in seconds. Whether you're going for dramatic glamour or a subtle makeup look, mascara is often that one non-negotiable product in our makeup routine. But while most of us automatically reach for black mascara at the beauty counter, have you considered whether it's actually the best colour for your features?

While black mascara has long reigned supreme in the beauty world, brown mascara is having its well-deserved moment. This often-overlooked shade might be the secret to achieving that natural yet polished look you've been after. The choice between brown and black mascara isn't just about colour preference – it can impact your entire makeup look, complement your natural features, and even affect how suitable your makeup appears for different occasions.

Let's dive into everything you need to know about choosing between brown and black mascara, so you can make the best choice for you!

Understanding Mascara Basics

Mascara is an essential part of any eye makeup look! Using a mascara in your makeup routine can enhance your lashes and add volume, length, and colour. With just a few swipes, mascara can help brighten the appearance of your eyes and complete your overall makeup look.

Understanding the basics of mascara can help you choose the right product for you. Mascara comes in various formulations, each designed to meet different needs. Here are a few key features you should consider:

Mascara Colour: can determine the overall effect—softer for brown, bolder for black
Mascara Formula: waterproof, tubing , volumising, lengthening, or curling, each has unique benefits
Mascara Brush Type: can affect the application and the overall appearance of your lashes

Black Mascara: The Classic Choice

There's a reason black mascara dominates the beauty aisles and holds a permanent spot in millions of makeup bags worldwide. This classic shade delivers unmatched drama and definition that's become synonymous with bold, beautiful lashes. When you want your eyes to make a statement, black mascara is your most powerful ally.

Black mascara is best when wanting to add contrast to your eye makeup, instantly making your lashes appear thicker and more voluminous against any skin tone. For those with naturally dark eyelashes, it enhances what you already have, while those with lighter lashes experience a more dramatic transformation. The intensity of black mascara can also make your eyes appear larger and more defined, creating that wide-awake look even on your most tired days.

The versatility of black mascara also makes it a makeup artist’s favourite. Whether you're creating a smoky eye or a natural look, black mascara can be applied lightly for subtle definition or built up for dramatic impact. It pairs perfectly with any eye shadow colour and complements every eyeliner shade, making it truly a universal choice!

Brown Mascara: The Subtle Enhancer

While often overlooked in favour of its darker counterpart, brown mascara has earned its place as the secret weapon for achieving that coveted no-makeup makeup look. This softer alternative offers a naturally enhanced appearance that can be more flattering than black, especially if you're seeking definition without intensity.

One of our favourite things about brown mascara is how versatile the shade is and it’s ability to enhance your features without overpowering them. Brown mascara works to add depth and dimension to your lashes while maintaining a soft, sophisticated appearance that's perfect for daytime wear. Think of it as the difference between using a harsh black eyeliner versus a soft brown pencil – the impact is there, but with a gentler touch.

For those with blue or green eyes, brown mascara can make your eye colour appear more vibrant without competing for attention. It's also an excellent choice if you have red hair, as it complements auburn tones beautifully while avoiding the sometimes harsh contrast that black mascara can create. The subtle warmth of brown mascara can also be more forgiving on mature eyes, as it doesn't create the stark contrast that can sometimes emphasise fine lines or wrinkles.

How to Choose Between Black and Brown Mascara

Selecting the right mascara colour for you can depend on a couple of factors:

Consider your natural colouring first—fair skin and light hair often pair best with brown mascara, while darker complexions typically shine with black.
Assess your eye colour—brown mascara can enhance blue or green eyes softly, while black mascara works to create more contrast.
The occasion—opt for brown mascara during the daytime or professional settings, and black mascara for evening events or when you want more definition.

Your makeup style and personal features can also play a crucial role! Minimalist makeup may benefit from brown's subtlety, while bold makeup styles may pair best with the intensity of black mascara.

Pro Tip: Having both mascara shades in your makeup bag provides ultimate versatility, allowing you to adapt your makeup look to almost any occasion.

Tips for Wearing Each Colour

When applying brown or black mascara, the application process is relatively the same. Start by using an eyelash curler before applying your mascara for a little extra lift. We recommend starting at the roots of your lash, wiggling the mascara wand side-to-side. In order to achieve even coverage, try using upward sweeping motions.

Lastly, depending on your desired makeup look, build layers gradually. Apply 1-2 coats for a more natural eye makeup look, and 3-4 for a more dramatic eye makeup look. You can also choose a waterproof mascara formula for a longer-lasting effect.

The Best Brown and Black Mascaras

Ready to shop for the perfect mascara for you? Here are some of our favorite e.l.f. mascara’s that are available in both brown and black shades:

Lash XTNDR Tubing Mascara: available in deep brown and pitch black
- Features: tubing technology, flexible tapered silicone brush
- Benefits: helps to create the look of lash extensions, clump-free and smudge-resistant
Lash 'N Roll Mascara: available in brown and black
- Features: curling formula, unique double-sided curved silicone brush
- Benefits: helps to separate, lift, and curl each lash
Big Mood Mascara: available in deep brown and black
- Features: volumising and lifting formula, hourglass-shaped brush
- Benefits: helps to create bold, lifted lashes with dramatic volume

Frequently Asked Questions About Brown and Black Mascara:

Q: Is There a Big Difference Between Brown and Black Mascara?

A: Yes, black and brown mascaras differ significantly in their visual impact and application across various makeup styles. Black mascara delivers dramatic, bold definition ideal for evening and high-intensity makeup looks, while brown mascara provides a softer, more natural enhancement suited to daytime and professional settings.

Q: What Does Brown Mascara Do for Your Eyes?

A: Brown mascara softens eye makeup by providing a more natural, subtle definition. It creates a gentler framing for the eyes compared to black mascara, making it ideal for:

Daytime and professional looks
Those wanting a less intense eye makeup appearance
Enhancing blue, green, and hazel eye colours without overwhelming them

Q: Does Brown Mascara Make Eyes Look Bigger?

A: Brown mascara can subtly enhance eye size by providing a softer, more natural definition that doesn't create harsh lines. While black mascara tends to create more dramatic contrast, brown mascara offers a gentler framing that can make eyes appear slightly larger and more open. However, the effect is more subtle compared to techniques like white or nude eyeliner on the waterline, which more dramatically create the illusion of larger eyes.

Q: Is Brown Mascara Better for Mature Eyes?

A: Brown mascara is often recommended for mature eyes because it:

Creates a softer, less harsh definition compared to black mascara
Provides a more natural, flattering look for aging skin

Brown vs. Black Mascara: Which Mascara Colour Should You Choose?

Understanding Mascara Basics

Black Mascara: The Classic Choice

Brown Mascara: The Subtle Enhancer

How to Choose Between Black and Brown Mascara

Tips for Wearing Each Colour

The Best Brown and Black Mascaras

Frequently Asked Questions About Brown and Black Mascara:

Related Articles:

Help

Discover e.l.f.

Services